**Kim Kardashian’s New Legal Drama *All’s Fair* Panned by Critics, Debuts at 0% on Rotten Tomatoes**
*Nov. 5, 2025, Published 7:47 a.m. ET*
Kim Kardashian’s much-anticipated new legal drama *All’s Fair* has come under heavy fire from critics, with many delivering brutal assessments of her acting skills. RadarOnline.com can reveal that the Ryan Murphy–created series, which premiered Tuesday, has been branded “the worst drama ever” and shockingly debuted at zero percent on Rotten Tomatoes.
### Ominous Signs Preceded the Release
Despite months of heavy promotion across Disney+ and Hulu, *All’s Fair* failed to meet expectations, with critics agreeing that the series was not worth the wait. Perhaps foreshadowing the disappointment, there were no preview screenings offered to critics—leaving both reviewers and the public to watch the first three episodes only on release day.
Ben Dowell of *The Times* delivered a scathing zero-star review, declaring: “This may be the worst TV drama ever.” USA Today’s Kelly Lawler echoed this sentiment, calling the show “the worst TV show of the year.”
### ‘Worst TV Show of the Year,’ Critics Say
Angie Han of *The Hollywood Reporter* criticized Kardashian’s performance as “stiff and affectless without a single authentic note,” adding that the show’s writing mirrored this lack of genuineness. Lucy Mangan of *The Guardian* opened her review with disbelief: “I did not know it was still possible to make television this bad… But I was wrong. *All’s Fair* is terrible. Fascinatingly, incomprehensibly, existentially terrible.”
RadarOnline.com previously revealed the harsh reactions to Kardashian’s debut acting performance in the series.
### Kim Kardashian’s Role and Cast
The reality star, 45, plays Allura Grant, a top divorce attorney featured in the Ryan Murphy–produced drama. The storyline follows a group of women lawyers who leave a male-dominated firm to start their own powerhouse practice.
Kardashian stars alongside an impressive, star-studded cast including Naomi Watts (57), Glenn Close (78), Sarah Paulson (50), and Niecy Nash (55). However, many viewers questioned why Murphy chose to cast Kardashian, given the wealth of established talent on the show.
### Performance Criticized as ‘Monotone’ and ‘Stiff’
Online reactions to Kardashian’s acting were overwhelmingly negative. Fans took to X (formerly Twitter) to describe her portrayal as “stiff” and “monotone.” One user wrote, “Kim Kardashian cannot act and she needs to stop touching her face.” Another added, “Lmao Kim is so monotone I can’t,” while a different viewer commented, “Trying to watch *All’s Fair* but I can’t with Kim Kardashian.”
Several fans questioned Murphy’s casting decision:
– “All those amazing actors and Ryan Murphy puts Kim Kardashian in it too… WTAF??? #AllsFair”
– “Need to understand why Ryan Murphy entertains Kim Kardashian’s acting career.”
– “Yeah, casting Kim Kardashian was the worst mistake they could’ve made for this show… it ruins the tone immediately because she cannot act. WHY WHY WHY.”
### Behind the Scenes: The Inspiration and Kardashian’s Approach
*All’s Fair* was first announced in December and marks the first series under Ryan Murphy’s new overall deal at Disney. The drama is reportedly partly inspired by Kardashian’s real-life lawyer, Laura Wasser, who represented her in her high-profile divorces from Kanye West and Kris Humphries.
Speaking about working with the acclaimed cast, Kardashian said:
“Working with a cast like this I wanted to make sure I was completely prepared. What I could control was absolutely knowing my lines, being on time and being super professional. These women are the greatest at what they do, and I just watched and learned every day. It was an honor, and I have just had the best time. Working with these women was like summer camp.”
—
Despite the excitement surrounding *All’s Fair*’s release, early feedback suggests the series struggles to live up to the hype, with many pointing to Kardashian’s performance as a weak spot in an otherwise high-profile production.
https://radaronline.com/p/kim-kardashian-new-tv-series-trounced-critics-alls-fair-existentially-terrible-crime-against-television/